 |
Twice-Weekly Briefing
Tuesday, November 3, 2026
Issue 261103-77
|
|
|
The MOC Brief
Health policy, priced and translated for self-funded plan sponsors
|
|
In This Edition
Five developments, and what each one costs you.
| 1. | An employer lost on every count over its tobacco surcharge, and the disclosure failures are the part to check in your own plan materials. | | 2. | The PBM fee disclosure rule is published, and the date that decides whether it reaches you is the start of your plan year. | | 3. | Employer costs for health benefits rose more than twice as fast as wages in private industry over the twelve months ending in September. | | 4. | A January 1 network cliff in Florida, where the carrier says about 85 percent of its employers there self-fund. | | 5. | Batched surprise billing disputes are capped at 50 line items and cannot combine claims from two different self-funded plans. |
|
|
| 1 · TOBACCO SURCHARGE · October 16, 2026 |
| A Judge Ruled Against Compass Group on All Six Counts Over a Tobacco Surcharge That Collected $47.9 Million |
| Judge Stephen R. Bough granted summary judgment to two participants and their class on all six counts on October 16, finding that Compass Group's tobacco surcharge broke ERISA's nondiscrimination rule, its disclosure requirements, its fiduciary duties and the plan's own terms. The surcharge ran $12 a week in plan year 2016 and $24 a week from plan year 2017 on, and the order puts the total collected at $47,960,937.87 from January 1, 2016 to May 20, 2026. Participants could drop the surcharge by finishing a free tobacco cessation course, but for plan years 2016 through the middle of 2024 the court found the plan lifted it only for the rest of that plan year and did not refund what had already been paid, which it held the statute requires. Compass revised the policy midway through plan year 2024 to reimburse retroactively, back to January 1, 2024, and the first enrollment guide to disclose that was for plan year 2025. The court also found the surcharge money was plan assets that the company placed in its general assets rather than segregating, and it deferred the damages figure and gave the parties fourteen days to brief it. |
|
MOC Perspective
If you run a tobacco surcharge with a cessation course as the way out, what this court held is not about whether you offer the course. It is that a participant who finishes it midyear has to get back what they already paid that year, and that your plan materials have to say so in writing. This is one district court rather than settled law, so treat it as a map of where the exposure sits rather than as a rule you are already breaking. The court also treated the surcharge dollars as plan assets, which makes holding them in your general account a separate breach from the disclosure problem.
What to do now
| ▪ | Pull your last three enrollment guides and confirm each one names the alternative standard, the retroactive refund and the physician accommodation. | | ▪ | Check whether finishing your cessation course in month seven refunds the first six months of surcharge, not just the weeks after. | | ▪ | Ask your TPA where surcharge dollars sit and confirm they are not pooled into your general account before your 2027 plan year opens. |
|
|
| Source: U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri, Mehlberg v. Compass Group USA, No. 24-cv-04179-SRB, order of October 16, 2026 |
|
| 2 · PBM DISCLOSURE · November 2, 2026 |
| Your Plan Year Start Date Decides Whether the New PBM Fee Disclosure Rule Reaches You in 2027 or 2028 |
| The date that decides whether Labor's new PBM fee disclosure rule reaches your plan is the start of your plan year, and that date is now fixed. The rule published in the Federal Register on November 2 as document 2026-22306, at 91 FR 69092, and it is applicable to plan years beginning on or after July 1, 2027. The regulation is separately effective January 4, 2027, which is when it takes force rather than when any plan owes a disclosure. Its summary describes the rule as affecting sponsors and other fiduciaries of large self-funded group health plans along with certain service providers to those plans. |
|
MOC Perspective
Nothing you owe changes on January 4. If your plan year begins in the second half of 2027 you are in the first group, and the renewal you negotiate next spring is the one that has to carry the language. If you run on the calendar year your first covered plan year starts in 2028, which buys you one more renewal cycle to get the contract right. Either way the work sits in the contract rather than in a compliance filing.
What to do now
| ▪ | Find your plan year start date and check whether it falls in the first half or the second half of 2027. | | ▪ | Put the disclosure requirement into the PBM contract you negotiate for the plan year beginning on or after July 1, 2027. | | ▪ | Ask your PBM which of the rule's required disclosures it already produces, and get the answer before your next renewal. |
|
|
| Source: Federal Register, Improving Transparency Into Pharmacy Benefit Manager Fee Disclosure, 91 FR 69092, published November 2, 2026 |
|
| 3 · BENEFIT COST TREND · October 30, 2026 |
| Employer Costs for Health Benefits in Private Industry Rose 6.4 Percent Over the Year Ending in September |
| The Bureau of Labor Statistics published the Employment Cost Index for September 2026 on October 30. Employer costs for health benefits in private industry rose 6.4 percent over the twelve months ending in September, not seasonally adjusted, up from 6.0 percent for the year ending in June and 6.1 percent for the year ending in September 2025. All benefits together rose 3.9 percent over the same twelve months, wages and salaries rose 3.1 percent, and in constant dollars wages and salaries fell 0.6 percent. The private industry estimates draw on about 6,600 establishments and roughly 28,000 occupational observations, and the index measures the change in the cost of labor rather than the level. BLS also said that beginning with December 2026 data, due January 29, 2027, the index will take on updated employment weights and drop workers' compensation costs. |
|
MOC Perspective
This is the series your bargaining counterparts and your CFO will quote, and it is a national index rather than your own experience. What it tells you is that the gap between what health benefits cost you and what you pay in wages is still widening, which is the arithmetic behind every cost shifting conversation you will have at this renewal. It also means this reading is not an outlier against the two before it, so a renewal quote in that range is not by itself evidence your plan is performing. The figure you actually need is your own per employee per month trend over the same twelve months, and that is a report to ask your TPA for.
What to do now
| ▪ | Pull your own health benefit cost trend for the twelve months ending September 2026 and set it against 6.4 percent. | | ▪ | Ask your broker for the last three renewals' quoted trend against actual trend so you can see the pattern. | | ▪ | Budget the plan year starting in 2027 on your own claims experience rather than on a national index. |
|
|
| Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employment Cost Index for September 2026, USDL-26-1620, released October 30, 2026 |
|
| 4 · NETWORK TERMINATION · October 29, 2026 |
| UnitedHealthcare and AdventHealth Have Until December 31 to Keep Florida Hospitals in the Employer Network |
| UnitedHealthcare's page on the negotiation, as updated October 29, says it issued notice earlier this year to end its AdventHealth contract in Florida effective January 1, 2027, and that network access runs through December 31. If no agreement is reached, the carrier lists employer-sponsored commercial plans, individual and family plans, Medicare Advantage and Florida Medicaid as going out of network on January 1. The carrier puts AdventHealth's costs about 30 percent above the average of all hospitals in its Florida commercial network, says AdventHealth has acquired more than two dozen Florida provider entities since 2023 and raised their costs 40 percent on average, and says that reimbursing AdventHealth since 2023 at the average rate of other systems in its Orlando and Tampa Bay commercial networks would have cut its commercial plan costs by nearly $550 million. Those figures are the carrier's own and no independent validator is named, and AdventHealth's page disputes none of them, saying only that it is not seeking rate increases above inflation and framing the dispute around denials, prior authorization and administrative barriers. The carrier also says approximately 85 percent of its Florida employers self-fund their health plan, which it explains means the employer pays the cost of care while the carrier administers benefits. |
|
MOC Perspective
If you are one of those Florida employers and you self-fund, the January 1 cliff would land on your claims rather than on the carrier's. That date starts the plan year for a calendar year plan and falls mid year for any other, and if the two sides do not reach agreement your members lose network access to a system holding their records. The carrier's own case is that current rates cost you money, and among its unnamed examples it puts one employer's savings at $10.2 million and another's at about $8 million. Neither page tells you whether your group sits in the affected book, and neither carries a member or employer count, so that is a question for your account team rather than for either website.
What to do now
| ▪ | Ask your UnitedHealthcare account team in writing whether your Florida members are in the affected book, before December 31. | | ▪ | Price your 2026 AdventHealth claims volume at out of network benefits so you know the exposure if the contract lapses without a deal. | | ▪ | Confirm your continuity of care terms for members in active treatment and get the carrier's answer in writing within two weeks. |
|
|
| Source: UnitedHealthcare, Network Negotiations with AdventHealth in Florida, page as updated October 29, 2026 |
|
| 5 · ARBITRATION RULES · October 29, 2026 |
| New Arbitration Guidance Spells Out a 50 Line Item Cap and the Bar on Batching Two Self-Funded Plans |
| The Departments of the Treasury, Labor and Health and Human Services issued guidance on October 29 on how batched and bundled disputes work in the federal arbitration process for surprise bills. Under the final rules a batched dispute cannot include more than 50 line items, and service code modifiers and anesthesia qualifying circumstances add-on codes do not count toward that 50. The batching definition applies to disputes whose open negotiation period begins on or after November 1, 2026, which is 90 calendar days after the Departments gave notice on August 3 that the supporting functionality would be available. The guidance says claims payable by different self-funded group health plans cannot be batched, and that this holds regardless of whether the same third-party administrator runs both plans. Items in a batch must also have been furnished within the same 30 business day period as the first item in the batch, and the cooling off period after a batched determination is 30 business days. |
|
MOC Perspective
In practice your providers open these, and your TPA answers them, so most of what changed is the arithmetic on your side of the ledger. A provider cannot roll claims from several of your plans into one case, so each plan gets its own determination and its own cooling off clock. The guidance also sets out how a plan is identified in the process, by its own tax identification number or by the sponsor's employer identification number plus the three digit plan number from the Form 5500, and later by a health plan registry number, which makes your records an operational question rather than a filing detail.
What to do now
| ▪ | Ask your TPA how many federal arbitration cases name your plan and get the count for the twelve months ending September 2026. | | ▪ | Confirm your TPA holds your plan's tax identification number and your three digit Form 5500 plan number correctly. | | ▪ | Add arbitration case counts and award amounts to your TPA's quarterly report before the 2027 plan year opens. |
|
|
| Source: Departments of the Treasury, Labor and Health and Human Services, Federal IDR guidance on batched and bundled qualified IDR items and services, October 29, 2026 |
|
|
The Bottom Line
The surcharge ruling is the uncomfortable one, because its exposure runs backward through documents you wrote years ago rather than forward into a renewal you have not negotiated yet. The PBM rule and the Florida network date are the easier problem, because both still have a date in front of them. The arbitration guidance changes little about how a dispute reaches you and quite a lot of what your TPA has to track. And the benefit cost figure carries no deadline at all, which is why it waits until a renewal quote makes it urgent.
|
|
|
Jude Odu
Founder and Principal, Model Optimal Care
Author of Model Optimal Care: End U.S. Healthcare Waste, One Health Plan at a Time
|
|
|
|